Re: Marxist-Leninist-Maoist response to Dr. Weizfeld PART 1

Before we start this, many thanks to Comrade Net for making sure we got this, we are very upset that Dona Newman withheld this from us. All links provided in this post must be clicked on, failure to do so shows a dismissive attitude, dismissive of those of us who fight the fight in World Revolution.

Let us start this off with gratitude, thank you for recognizing the failings of Leon Trotsky. Your acknowledging of the failings of Leon Trotsky and seeing issues within Trotskyism is much appreciated, Joseph Stalin is blamed to much when he was merely a continuation of Vladimir Lenin. We do however recognize Joseph Stalin as making serious contributions to Marxism, to us Leon Trotsky is minor in comparison. Keeping the facts in mind, Joseph Stalin was not all powerful in Russia and it is a fact that the NKVD was riddled with serious corruption, even standard Marxist-Leninists recognize this. There is zero evidence of the 'Testament' even existing aside from Mythic-Western Sources. Leon Trotsky although having some very valid ideas was himself a rightist-opportunist, although we are not truly convinced that Leon Trotsky was a Fascist collaborator as the majority of our Marxist-Leninist Comrades seem to be convinced. It is more likely that Leon Trotsky knew that the 'Testament' had been a set of notes on a personal manner considering Stalin's rudeness. Joseph Stalin was known to be looking after Vladimir Lenin's health at the time and the doctors told Lenin not to read Newspapers and so Stalin yelled at Lenin's wife when she gave in to Lenin's insistence on reading Newspapers. Joseph Stalin and Vladimir Lenin's wife Nadezhda Krupskaya had come to terms with each-other later on, this is well known, Leon Trotsky did not have mass Russian support and he was out of touch with Russians unlike Joseph Stalin. This should be enough to make it clear that what actually happened is that when the Myth of a “Testament” was first made, Leon Trotsky was actually truthful when he wrote:

Eastman asserts in several places that the Central Committee has “concealed” from the party a large number of documents of extraordinary importance, written by Lenin during the last period of his life. (The documents in question are letters on the national question, the famous “Testament,” etc.) This is pure slander against the Central Committee of our party. Eastman’s words convey the impression that Lenin wrote these letters, which are of an advisory character and deal with the inner-party organization, with the intention of having them published. This is not at all in accordance with the facts.
During his illness, Lenin repeatedly addressed letters and proposals to the leading bodies and congresses of the party. It must be definitely stated that all these letters and suggestions were invariably delivered to their destination and they were all brought to the knowledge of the delegates to the Twelfth and Thirteenth Congresses, and have invariably exercised their influence on the decisions of the party. If all of these letters have not been published, it is because their author did not intend them to be published. Comrade Lenin has not left any “Testament”; the character of his relations to the party, and the character of the party itself, preclude the possibility of such a “Testament.”

Some time after Trotsky realized that the Party of Lenin would never accept him he clearly decided that his best position in life was to embrace the Myth by Eastman. Trotskyists universally claim that Vladimir Lenin was to name Leon Trotsky as his successor, but this is a fallacious claim backed by nothing but Trot Mythology. Indeed, we have a bigger issue with Trotskyism and Trotskyists than we do with Trotsky himself, if something in the work of Trotsky is correct we can adopt it, if something is incorrect we reject it and even denounce it. Marxism-Leninism-Maoism was declared originally in the 1980s by the Revolutionary Internationalist Movement, synthesizing Maoism and Marxism-Leninism before this Maoism was a very empty word. It is also important to recognize that Maoism is not Mao Zedong Thought. However is is equally important to recognize that Maoism is Marxism-Leninism-Maoism. Marxism-Leninism-Maoism can never recognize Trotskyism as anything but Crypto-Fascism yet Marxism-Leninism-Maoism can recognize contributions of Leon Trotsky yet this is not done without major reservations. Marxism-Leninism-Maoism has some reservations about Lenin, Stalin and Mao yet at the same time we recognize these Revolutionaries to be very important, so as Maoists our reservations towards Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin will not be as intense as our reservations towards Leon Trotsky who was known to be a liar and a extremist-collaborator to Western Chauvinism in ways that Joseph Stalin had not been, that is not to say that Joseph Stalin was without opportunism, he clearly was but Leon Trotsky was much worse.

Although critical of some of the statements made in the work Federation of Palestinian and Hebrew Nations we remain open to it, as we said before all other attempts at a Peace Process have failed. Joseph Stalin's recognition of the Zionist State was his greatest error ever. Not all of us fully understand Bundism, but Panther C.O.D.E really does understand it, we understand a lot more thanks to how much they explained to us using Dialectical Materialism, there is a Jewish Nation, it is not a fantasy, and Joseph Stalin's dismissal of the Jewish Bund shows just how far he was willing to go in order to placate to the errors of Vladimir Lenin.

Your questioning of the Kuomintung has merit to it, but this does not disqualify the proven principle of Primary versus Secondary contradiction, you yourself follow it by trying to force Young Jewish Lumpen Radicals that want nothing to do with electoral politics to participate in in Imperialist voting racket while at the same time embracing lies against Nicolas Manduro. As we have dwelling places in Venezuela and we know full well that Bernie Sanders lied about Venezuela by lying about Manduro calling him a Dictator. Young Jewish Lumpen Radicals with connections to the Middle East and Africa boycott your mailing list called 'Jewish Socialist Bund' which is full of RadLibs posing as Socialists, the Young Jewish Lumpen Radicals favor Max Blumenthal, this same Max Blumenthal was favored by the five martyrs of the Bundist Movement and today is favored by both Comrade Net and Dona Newman. Poor People of Color generally distrust the Social Democratic flavor of that mailing list. So even though you follow Primary versus Secondary contradiction in favor of Liberalism you still follow it, you do this clearly in ignorance, no one going as far as you have for Palestine and World Revolution could be a Shill, but you are still ignorant and very disconnected. How many people have come and gone, shined brightly and then left, if you had the Young Jewish Lumpen Radicals you may actually have a Revolutionary force.

As Chairman Mao stated in his work The Mass Line:

The masses are the real heroes, while we ourselves are often childish and ignorant, and without this understanding, it is impossible to acquire even the most rudimentary knowledge.

Comrade Net and Dona Newman understand the true Jewish Masses, they have applied theories that you started to conditions that actually work, but remain isolated from the Jewish Masses because of your arrogance and ignorance of the Jewish Masses choosing to look only at the Customer Service Working Classes claiming Jewishness and not the Jewish Lumpen. Marx did not just hate the Lumpen, he hated Jews too, he was great and bringing us Scientific Socialism but he was incorrect about where Revolution would happen. Likewise all the true Anarchist Comrades are Lumpen and they too are mistrusting towards the RadLibs you associate with, there are a lot of RadLibs pretending to be Anarchists but we are the ones who(that is to say, we the Maoists) actually work together with the real Anarchists, you are disconnected from them as well. The PFLP is Marxist-Leninist, the DFLP is Marxist-Leninist-Maoist (according to those of us in Third World Liberation) funny enough Comrade Net keeps criticizing Third World Liberation as miss-categorizing both the PFLP and the DFLP. It is good that we all agree that the PFLP, the DFLP, Fatah and Hamas must show a United Front against the Primary contradictions of Zionism and Americanism.

Yes thanks to the efforts of Panther C.O.D.E we now recognize Jewish Nationality as something based in Torah Culture and Traditional Covenant Religiosity. The one who expresses this the best and in a way that must be propagated as universally acceptable is Comrade Net the Cleric of the Bundist Movement, as Comrade Net actually knows how to speak for the Jewish Masses showing the correctness of it all to Panther C.O.D.E, this has led to Panther C.O.D.E expressing this to both Marxist-Leninist-Maoist Action and Third World Liberation. We officially will be giving the Jewish Nation and the Jewish Bundist Diaspora Movement full recognition out in our newest MLM literature.

The Libria Consolidation Party is absolutely reprehensible. It seems that there has been trouble getting the Jewish Manifesto organized, we know that Comrade Net has had plans to find everything that consists of that Manifesto to you so that you can contribute to it giving your academic twist to it, clearly your response to us was months ago, so we can see that there has been delay. Your assessment of Gilad Atzmon and all of the other members of the Libria Consolidation Party is correct they are Crypto-Fascists as are all Trotskyists, you should recognize these Trots for what they are, if Trotsky knew that his dangerous compromises would have led to Trotskyism finally evolving into such a incoherent Fascist ideology he probably would have been more honest, if he had been more honest he would have sent apology letters to Stalin, if he had sent apology letters to Stalin maybe Stalin would have been more understanding to the Anti-Fascist movements that he mistrusted, and that would have saved many lives from the evil armies of Hitler. Trotsky recognized Jewish National Identity too late, this lateness on the part of Leon Trotsky has shown incoherent flip-flopping on Trotsky's end is why there are so many splits in Trotskyism. Now for the first time ever a coherent version of Trotskyism has emerged. For a coherent version of Trotsky ism to emerge means parts of Trotsky's work must be excluded and other parts get embraced by default. The notorious League for the Fourth International is a Trotskyist organization that supports Child Molestation and as well as the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, you can not act like the systemic problems of Trotskyism are limited only to the Libria Consolidation Party. The International Socialist Organization which is now dissolved rejected any type of Self-Defense for those that could not even engage in peaceful protest. Pacifism and Nonviolence has proven to be the downfall of the Leftists around the World, the Oslo Peace Deals are directly responsible for the coming destruction of Palestine a Genocide that all Jews will be blamed for, even though that is not fair that is what will most likely happen. Trotskyism's popular monopoly on Socialist language is user friendly to Liberals, it has had disastrous consequences.

Bernie Sanders has not put Socialism on the agenda, this is the same folly as calling China a Socialist Country, China never made it to Socialism not because of the popular Mythic rational of historical revisionism everyone seems to believe but because Mao moved away from his own policies and when Lin Biao tried to save Mao's line from Mao himself he had Lin Bioa murdered. China is not going through a New Economic Policy as all of the foolish China Cultists proclaim, those in the west following the Deng Xiaoping Theory make good allies on many subjects to be sure, but they muddy the waters with their revisionism, China is not Socialist, we support China in their struggle against U.S Aggression we also call out the Pro-Trump Hong Kong Protesters that light people on fire for speaking Mandarin. At the same time we reject China's Socially Imperialist policies for Africa. Your lack of understanding Geopolitics is dangerous. Those well versed in Geopolitics must understand your arguments on Auto-Determination over Self-Determination because those are correct ideas but you also need to learn Geopolitics which is why you need to capitulate to Comrade Net and Dona Newman when it comes to the facts about Assad, you ignore Syrians and the last note you gave publicly to Uri Adiah a Syrian Jew that knew much more about Syria than you ever have was disgraceful. Are you aware that every time that the Gas Attacks accrued it was the work of Al Nusra? The Al Nusra Front even staged events using a repetitively debunked hoax called the White Helmets. Indeed there should be Auto-Determination for both Syrians and Kurds, this would mean that Syrians should be allowed to move back into the stolen lands that Kurds brutally took away from them. Syrian Sovereignty must be resorted, in return the Kurds must be granted Semi-Territorial Autonomy and full National-Cultural Autonomy in to exist as a Diaspora Nations free in the Lands of Syria, Iraq and Iran. The sad part is that this will never be realized because Ba'athism has the heart of the Syrian People and Bookchinite Imperialism controls the collective consciousness of Rojava. National-Cultural Autonomy and Auto-Determination was what Uri Adiah tried to promote but he is dead now. In case you can not find Uri Adiah's work on Syrians and Kurds it this work titled The Syrian War: Confusing Subject rather disgracefully you wrote in commentary to him

Besides the Assad apologies there is an error in theory here that refers to a "Pan-Arab Nationalism" which does not even exist. Pan-Arabism as launched by Nasser did not call for a single centralised State for all Arabs. Pan-Arabism recognises the various Arab Nations in the larger community of the Arabic culture. The support of Kurdish national-cultural autonomy is fine but everybody knows that Assad has already rejected that proposition, mainly because the Kurdish territories are where the oil fields are.

you claim he makes Assad apologies, yes he should not have used the words "Pan-Arab Nationalism" but he made no Assad apologies. We are not trying to attack you Dr. Weizfeld everyone makes errors, your errors however cause great harm, this was written by someone that was part of the Lenin-Mao Communist Union both Dona Newman and Comrade Net agree with Poc Eral's assessment here. In this work by Poc Eral titled What the Bundists knew about Syria you can see how wrong you have been on the matter of Syria. All Turkish involvement must stop. The Turkish Government is a dishonest broker. Russia and Iran are the only honest mediators in this case, Iran being the better. We know about the bogus articles you post out on Facebook with weapons written in Cyrillic. We see everything you post on Facebook.  Many going through actual traumas in the real World are to afraid to contact you because you are not always in reality. This is not because you are irrational but it is because you like to twist reality to your own liking. You will trust in anything that fits your faith-based system of political idealism. You need to correct this error. Bernie Sanders promoted Social Democracy and he did not challenge Imperialism. Bernie Sanders did not speak of De-Colonization, we can recall how much all of the other members of the Jewish Bundist Diaspora Movement wanted to call out Bernie Sanders as a form of controlled opposition. He even rejects BDS, he may not openly oppose BDS's right to the First Amendment, he may have refused to join in AIPAC, but he also for a second time capitulated to the Democrats because he is nothing more than a Social Democrat trying to restore the long dead Franklin D. Roosevelt (the World War II President that had Japanese Americans thrown into Camps for reasons of National Security) and John F. Kennedy. In fear of losing their Chairman, the other Bundists tried to form a critical support campaign for Sanders because they needed your support, the torture this was to them was unspeakable, a Canadian Jew telling the American Jews how to do their politics, this was cruel and you have never apologized to Dona Newman or Comrade Net for this. Dona Newman, comrade Net and the five martyrs took theory that originated from you to new heights, without the five martyrs we would have never admitted that National-Cultural autonomy was correct, you did not understand what you actually gave birth to, you still don't. What you have done in Palestine inspire many, we hope you can return to Palestine before it is removed and all the Jews are blamed, as Communists we have the obligation to protected the marginalized which includes the Jews (Bundist Comrades). You do not understand that you gave birth to a new theoretical wave superior to that email joke of yours called 'Jewish Socialist Bund' those RadLibs have nothing on the Diaspora (Maoist/Anarchist) Autonomists that you literally created, sometimes creation goes beyond creator, you still don't understand. As much as you offend us, you inspire us too. You understand what Apartheid is, what Zionism is, but you need to fully take in what Americanism is to all of this. Marxist-Leninist-Maoist Action (a Indigenous Native American MLM Revolutionary Militia) asks Dr. Weizfeld; Do you understand that the American Flag is to us what the Nazi flag is to you? How can you ignore a Genocide that was larger than the Holocaust? A Holocaust that lasted over 500 years and it is still happening. Very soon, we will not exist.

Why could you not come out against Americanism before? You don't like to compromise with the State, yet you want people to vote in Imperialist States, voting does not work it never will. This is the contradiction that hurts the most. Americanism gave birth to Nazism. Hitler based his program of Genocide on the Genocide of Native Americans these are historical facts. Your not incorrect about the Germanic/Anglo-Saxon power of supremacy in the United States, but you never understood how Neo-Colonialist Obama was, it took you a long time to realize that Gun-Control is Right-Wing.

With the murder of George Floyd, maybe you can see now that Revolution is the only answer, although we have some critical optimism about the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone we sure hope that you don't ask them to join in reformist elections. Moving into the Civil Society means creating our own Governments in waiting the time of voting or dreaming of Jewish Presidents will only hold back your Comrades. You need to start to treat them as Equals. Dona Newman and Comrade Net have the correct line within Bundist logic, they may teach you something. The United Fronts must happened, already Third Worldists and Anarchists are collaborating with us the Maoists, we hope that Bundists join us.

Just letting you know, Afro-American is better than saying Afican American, but he terms Black or New Afrikan is more correct. No one needs to be Amerikan.

The Vanguard Circle, yes we have now learned of this, it would have been better if Dona would not have withheld this, you need to be sure to thank Comrade Net for getting this to us. He tried mailing all of this to Panther C.O.D.E amore than once and some of their members already had gotten it, but from time to time members of Panther C.O.D.E get arrested. 

If we don't build the necessary Vanguards the Revolution may not be realized. The events of May 27th of 2019, May 30th of 2019 and June 8th of 2019 in many ways was a four-shadowing of what is happening now, we know that you knew this was coming.

Your accusations against Nicolas Maduro are incorrect, many of us that are part of Third World Liberation (a MLM group of World Revolutionaries) live in Venezuela. This work by Poc Eral sheds even further light on your incorrect statement, your distrust of Assad is at least understandable but your dislike for Manduro is borderline racist. This note by Poc Eral shows that Edgardo Lander was disrupting the Worker Based Democracy, this work is titled What the Bundists knew about Venezuela
explains everything, we can remember when you supported Obama the NeoColonial President but you can't even afford to support the People's Choice for President, that is very reactionary, another case of trying to twist reality to suit your idealism. Nicolas Maduro has begun to arm Revolutionaries throughout South America. It is one thing to criticism because he should just become a Maoist but it is another thing to twist reality.

It is a lack of Bureaucracy that is allowing for Privatization, all of this proves Mao's Theory correct that after the revolution there will be further need for further Revolution until the entire State is Proletarian. There is more participation in Venezuela's Government than there is in America, you need to get off your high horse seriously. How long has it been since you went to Venezuela? Did you ever meet the local population? Or do you just talk to the European Settler Population? Evo Morales's overthrow makes the presence of Nicolas Maduro more important than before, what the People need is a Marxist-Leninist-Maoist Revolution.

You have shown yourself to be very out of touch with reality, perhaps these riots have awaken you. How many Syrians, Venezuelans and Lumpen Squatters have to die before you join us Dr. Weizfeld, you talk of United Fronts but you don't want to support other Revolutionaries unless they conform to your out of touch Idealism. This is why Dona Newman did not want us seeing this, she knew how offense and eurocentric you would seem to us. We have a Part 2 for you tomorrow.